Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Ketchum's avatar

I think there is an important distinction here between crime and injustice. Crime is defined relative to a legal system; injustice is not. Governments can criminalize conduct that violates no one’s rights, while also legalizing conduct that would otherwise be recognized as a serious rights violation. So I’m reluctant to look for a single moral or psychological cause of “crime,” because the category itself depends partly on what legislators decide to prohibit.

I would put the deeper issue differently. The main disposition underlying crime is a willingness to violate whatever rules a legal system classifies as criminal. The morally important disposition is a willingness to violate others' perfect rights. Those categories overlap, but they are not identical.

Poverty might help explain some particular offenses without explaining others, just as wealth plainly does not prevent people or organizations from committing serious wrongs. I therefore think we should keep the causal question, “Why do people violate laws?” separate from the normative question, “Why do people violate the rights of others?” The second question seems considerably more fundamental.

Ian Ferguson's avatar

In America it is a fact that the wealthiest blacks, on average have higher rates of crime than the poorest Whites.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?