There’s a common belief that criminals commit crimes because they’re poor. That eliminating poverty is the path to a safe society.
The belief is understandable.
Proponents look at high-crime areas, notice that they’re usually also poor, and assume people are committing crimes out of desperation. They might think of movies like Aladdin, where the protagonist steals fruit to feed himself.
“Gotta eat to live, gotta steal to eat.” - From Aladdin’s One Jump Ahead song.
Unfortunately, this viewpoint is not only wrong, it is dangerously wrong.
Most people don’t understand the difference between correlation and causation. They see a correlation (high crime areas are also poor areas) and they do the natural human thing of putting themselves in that position. They empathize. They imagine what it would be like if they were poor. “Well, I might have to commit crimes too, if I were desperate enough.”
Ironically, it’s very hard for a person capable of empathy to put themselves in the shoes of a psychopath. It’s hard to imagine simply being incapable of empathy.
In a broader sense, it’s harder for good people to truly understand how evil people function. It might not even be possible.
This is the same fundamental error that people commit when they fail to see psychopaths for who they are. They assume everyone is like them. That everyone else’s brain is fundamentally sharing the same machinery, the same soul, in religious parlance.
This is a fatal error, and a conceited one at that.
A significant number of people do not feel empathy. These people do not commit crimes out of desperation. They commit crimes out of compulsion, or out of sadistic pleasure, or out of peer pressure and a lack of moral principles, or any number of other reasons.
The fact is that some people are just evil.
Even people who delusionally believe that everyone has a soul must admit that there is no way in which desperation would lead to crimes such as rape, murder, arson, and so on. Theft, maybe. But even that is almost never out of desperation.
Most good people who are thrust into desperation will do anything to avoid committing crime.
To quote another movie:
“… some men aren’t looking for anything logical, like money. They can’t be bought, bullied, reasoned, or negotiated with. Some men just want to watch the world burn.” - The Dark Knight.
Do criminals who steal because they’re truly desperate exist? Yes, but it’s rare. I’ve read of cases where a criminal steals something, leaves an apologetic note behind, and then later compensates their victim once they have a firmer footing in life. But this is an extremely rare exception that proves the rule.
So why are poor places full of criminals?
Because the kind of people who commit crimes are also the kind of people who cannot build functional societies.
Society requires empathy, cooperation, trade, and forward thinking with long time horizons. The more people who cannot form functional human bonds or think one step ahead live in an area, the worse it’ll be. Anyone who’s focused on destroying rather than building is a net drag on society. It’s as simple as that.
And destroying is far easier than building. It can take years to build a house. Someone can burn it down in an hour. The ratio of builders to destroyers in society has to be heavily weighted towards the builders.
High crime neighborhoods, all the way to high crime countries, are so because of the kind of people who live there.
You can’t just drop a pallet of cash into a place like that and expect it to get better. It sounds farcical but that’s essentially what a lot of government programs amount to. Welfare, foreign aid, etc., all center on the very anti-philosophical idea that people can be better if you just give them more stuff.
The truth is that people get better if they want to, if they work hard on it, and over many years, slowly, bit by bit. Talk to anyone recovering from drug addiction or alcoholism. Ask them if being given a bunch of cash at the height of their addiction would have helped them or just made their addictions harder.
Or ask them if lecturing them on being better would have helped, or if the internal desire to get better is what drove them to breaking their bad habits.
I think we all know what they’d say.
And it goes further than that. There are limits to how much a person can improve themselves (assuming they even want to). People hold onto bad ideas and, all too often, the ideas don’t die until the people carrying them do. Societal betterment is therefore an intergenerational parenting project, far more than any kind of economic intervention.
That’s something that’s hard for people to accept because it means that, by and large, the best you can do is lead by example. Build a good, moral, virtuous life that others would want to emulate.
But you can’t bribe a criminal into being a good person. And evil doesn’t respond to reason. It’s just not how people work. And it’s especially not how criminals work.
You can make a criminal richer. You can’t make them good.
If you would like to support my work, please consider becoming a supporter! I’ve been busy building websites and tools to help people self-actualize. Most of them are free, some have paid features. From relocating to a freer state and county and researching hazards near your home, to planning your garden. Check out all The Liberty Lookout projects here.




I think there is an important distinction here between crime and injustice. Crime is defined relative to a legal system; injustice is not. Governments can criminalize conduct that violates no one’s rights, while also legalizing conduct that would otherwise be recognized as a serious rights violation. So I’m reluctant to look for a single moral or psychological cause of “crime,” because the category itself depends partly on what legislators decide to prohibit.
I would put the deeper issue differently. The main disposition underlying crime is a willingness to violate whatever rules a legal system classifies as criminal. The morally important disposition is a willingness to violate others' perfect rights. Those categories overlap, but they are not identical.
Poverty might help explain some particular offenses without explaining others, just as wealth plainly does not prevent people or organizations from committing serious wrongs. I therefore think we should keep the causal question, “Why do people violate laws?” separate from the normative question, “Why do people violate the rights of others?” The second question seems considerably more fundamental.
In America it is a fact that the wealthiest blacks, on average have higher rates of crime than the poorest Whites.